Testosterone, Y Chromosomes, and Other Manly Excuses (with Matthew Gutmann)

Are men “naturally” violent? Are they hardwired to provide and protect? Does their DNA demand they stray? These questions persist in debates about masculinity, but they’re often answered with lazy biology.

In this episode, anthropologist Matthew Gutmann dismantles biologically grounded gender essentialist myths.

Drawing on decades of research—from fatherhood in Mexico to gender shifts in China—Gutmann shows how culture, history, and politics shape what we call “masculinity.” We talk about the dangers of blaming “male nature,” how fatherhood gets redefined across cultures, and why understanding men as human beings first opens the door to more freedom and accountability.

His book is called Are Men Animals? How Modern Masculinity Sells Men Short.

Full transcript available at relationscapes.org. 

Show Notes

• “Detoxing Masculinity,” with Ronald Levant and Shana Pryor
• “Black and Beyond the Binary,” with KB Brookins
• “Masculinity, More Liberated and Free,” with Frederick Joseph
• “Learning about Today’s Masculinity from the Ancient Romans," with Mike Pope

About the Guest

Matthew Gutmann is Professor Emeritus of Anthropology at Brown University. His research and teaching has focused on studies of men and masculinities; public health; politics; and the military. His latest book is Are Men Animals? How Modern Masculinity Sells Men Short.